Pakistan’s first minister in Delhi since 2025 war wasn’t India’s invitee, Al Jazeera reports; Congress attacks ‘red carpet’

AIAI-generated analysis published under the editorial responsibility of Rohit Sinnas. How it works →

Map of the countries in the story: Pakistan's first minister in Delhi since 2025 war wasn't India's invitee, Al Jazeera reports; Congress attacks 'red carpet'
63 outlets analyzed in 46 countries and 15 languages · 5 quoted
See the 46 countries

Armenia, Australia, Bangladesh, Bulgaria, Burundi, Cambodia, Canada, Egypt, France, Germany, Hong Kong, Hungary, India, Ireland, Italy, Japan, Kenya, Kuwait, Lebanon, Malaysia, Malta, Mexico, Nepal, New Zealand, Nigeria, Oman, Pakistan, Philippines, Qatar, Romania, Saudi Arabia, Singapore, South Africa, South Korea, Spain, Sri Lanka, Syria, Taiwan, Thailand, Trinidad and Tobago, Turkey, Ukraine, United Arab Emirates, United Kingdom, Uzbekistan, Vietnam

Bottom line

Pakistani minister Musadik Malik arrived in Delhi on November 20 for an SCO forum, the first such visit since the May 2025 war. No bilateral meeting is announced and New Delhi says its Pakistan policy is unchanged, while India’s Congress party attacks the invitation.

Across the press: The Times of India quotes Congress accusing the Modi government of a red carpet for Malik; Al Jazeera reports Delhi invited a different minister.

Key points

Source base: 5 outlets read in full (India, Pakistan, Turkey, Qatar), selected from 63 analyzed.

  • 1 of 5 · Al Jazeera only
    India’s invitation was addressed to Pakistan’s minister for national heritage and culture, Aurangzeb Khan Khichi, and Islamabad chose to send Malik without saying why.
    Al Jazeera, citing Indian media quoting diplomatic sources; PML-N leader Khurram Dastgir Khan told Al Jazeera the choice was deliberate.
  • 1 of 5 · The Tribune only
    Indian authorities cleared Malik to visit the Taj Mahal, Delhi Haat, Humayun’s Tomb and Qila Rai Pithora but denied his request to visit the Hazrat Nizamuddin shrine on security grounds.
    The Tribune, citing Indian government sources.
  • 1 of 5 · Al Jazeera only
    No India-Pakistan bilateral meeting has been announced, and New Delhi maintains there will be no bilateral engagement with Pakistan until terrorism is addressed.
    Al Jazeera, citing the absence of any announcement, foreign ministry spokesperson Randhir Jaiswal’s October 28 briefing, and Hindustan Times foreign affairs editor Rezaul Hasan Laskar.
  • 4 of 5 · reported separately
    Pakistan’s climate change minister Musadik Malik arrived in New Delhi on November 20, received by chargé d’affaires Saad Warraich, to lead Pakistan’s delegation at the first SCO Civilizational Dialogue Forum, becoming the first Pakistani federal minister in India since the May 2025 fighting and since Bilawal Bhutto Zardari’s May 2023 Goa trip.
    Pakistan High Commission, via The Express Tribune; independently reported by Al Jazeera, The Tribune and The Times of India; Yeni Akit calls it the first high-level visit since last year’s tension.
  • 2 of 5 · reported separately
    India’s opposition Congress party attacked the Modi government for inviting a Pakistani minister despite the Pahalgam attack.
    The Times of India, quoting Congress spokesperson Supriya Shrinate and J&K Congress president Tariq Hameed Karra; The Express Tribune also reports Congress questioning the invitation.
What to watch
  • November 21Malik addresses the forum and has said he will take up India’s cross-border terrorism concerns in that statement, which could set the visit’s tone.
  • November 22The forum closes; any reported sideline encounter between Malik and Indian officials would be the first sign of contact beyond the SCO frame.
  • Before August 2027India decides its level of representation at the SCO leaders’ summit Pakistan hosts in Islamabad, the larger test this visit foreshadows.

Full analysis

What happened Why it matters How each country tells it Where accounts conflict Room for disagreement Our assessment Sources and evidence

What happened

Pakistan’s climate change minister, Musadik Malik, landed in New Delhi on Friday, November 20, and was met at the airport by Pakistan’s chargé d’affaires, Saad Ahmad Warraich, the Pakistan High Commission said in a post on X carried by The Express Tribune. He leads Pakistan’s delegation at the first Shanghai Cooperation Organisation Civilisational Dialogue Forum, held at Delhi’s Purana Qila from November 20 to 22. Narendra Modi proposed the forum at last year’s SCO summit in Tianjin, Al Jazeera reports, and India invited all ten member states, according to The Express Tribune. Malik is the first Pakistani federal minister in India since the two countries fought a four-day war in May 2025, and the first since then-foreign minister Bilawal Bhutto Zardari attended SCO talks in Goa in May 2023.

The war followed the April 2025 attack in Pahalgam, in Indian-administered Kashmir, in which gunmen killed 26 civilians. India blames Pakistan; Islamabad denies involvement. India downgraded ties and suspended the Indus Waters Treaty, and Pakistan suspended trade and closed its airspace to Indian airlines, The Express Tribune notes. Al Jazeera adds that a court of arbitration in The Hague ruled on August 31 that India could not suspend the treaty unilaterally, a jurisdiction New Delhi rejects; that Indian and Pakistani naval vessels collided in the Arabian Sea in September; and that neither country has had a high commissioner in the other’s capital since 2019.

How Malik came to be the one in Delhi is reported only by Al Jazeera. Citing Indian media quoting diplomatic sources, it says India’s invitation was addressed to Pakistan’s minister for national heritage and culture, Aurangzeb Khan Khichi. Pakistan’s Foreign Office said on November 6 only that it had received an invitation, and Islamabad has not explained its choice. Khurram Dastgir Khan, a former defense and foreign minister and senior figure in the governing PML-N, told Al Jazeera the substitution was deliberate: it "lets Pakistan take part as an SCO member without being seen to buy into India’s framing or showcase."

New Delhi’s handling has been tight. At an October 28 briefing, foreign ministry spokesperson Randhir Jaiswal said India had invited "all SCO members" "as per established practice" and that "Post the Pahalgam attack, we have a Pakistan policy. That Pakistan policy remains in place; there has been no change." No bilateral meeting has been announced. The Tribune, citing government sources, reports that the High Commission asked for Malik to visit five sites; after a security assessment, Indian authorities cleared the Taj Mahal, Delhi Haat, Humayun’s Tomb and Qila Rai Pithora but refused the Hazrat Nizamuddin shrine on security grounds.

Modi opened the forum with a call for dialogue, saying mutual trust is the most basic condition for harmony and grows when people feel they share something in common, according to Yeni Akit, which drew on his office’s statement. On the sidelines, Malik struck a conciliatory note to The Tribune: "I think all of our relationships in the region are in flux, as the politics are shifting very fast." He added that "Singularity only requires a monologue. Dialogue is about diversity." Asked about India’s terrorism concerns, he told reporters, in remarks The Express Tribune carried from an ANI video, "I think tomorrow, once I give my statement, we’ll have a lot of conversations."

In Indian domestic politics the visit landed as a provocation. The Times of India quotes Congress spokesperson Supriya Shrinate accusing the government of "rubbing salt into the wounds of Pahalgam victims’ families" and saying Malik "had openly threatened just a few months ago to chop off the hands of Indians," a charge no other outlet in this set reports. Jammu and Kashmir Congress president Tariq Hameed Karra accused the BJP of "double standards."

Why it matters

The SCO has been one of the few rooms the two countries share since joining in 2017, and its calendar now runs through Pakistan. Islamabad took the rotating chair on September 1 and hosts the leaders’ summit in August 2027, the month both countries mark 80 years of independence. Indian officials have told local media they will decide their level of representation closer to the date. Every SCO contact until then is a rehearsal for whether Modi travels.

The precedents cut both ways. Bhutto Zardari’s Goa visit ended with S. Jaishankar calling him a "promoter, justifier and spokesperson of a terrorism industry"; Jaishankar’s October 2024 Islamabad trip produced pleasantries and no talks, and the war followed seven months later. Malik’s Saturday statement, which he has tied to India’s terrorism concerns, decides which precedent this visit follows. At home, Congress is attacking Modi for being too soft, which narrows the government’s room for any gesture beyond the multilateral minimum.

How each country tells it

  • The Tribune · India · original reporting
    Citing Indian government sources, it treats Malik’s trip as a list of site requests: the Pakistan High Commission asked for five visits, and security officials cleared the Taj Mahal, Delhi Haat, Humayun’s Tomb and Qila Rai Pithora but refused the Hazrat Nizamuddin shrine.
  • The Times of India · India · original reporting
    It reports the visit almost entirely through the opposition Congress party, whose spokesperson Supriya Shrinate accused the Modi government of rubbing salt into Pahalgam victims’ wounds and said Malik had once threatened to chop off Indians’ hands.
  • tribune.com.pk · Pakistan · original reporting
    The Express Tribune reports the arrival from the Pakistan High Commission’s post on X and stresses Malik’s line that dialogue requires distinct identities, adding that he deferred India’s terrorism concerns to his statement the next day.
  • Yeni Akit · Turkey · carries Indian Prime Minister’s Office
    It leads with Modi’s opening speech calling for dialogue, mutual trust and harmony, citing India’s Prime Minister’s Office, and mentions Malik’s arrival in two sentences as the first high-level visit since last year’s tension.
  • Al Jazeera · Qatar · original reporting
    Datelined Islamabad, its analysis measures the visit against Pakistan’s hosting of the SCO leaders’ summit in August 2027 and asks whether contact limited to SCO business could bring Modi to Islamabad.

Where accounts conflict

The two most detailed Indian-facing accounts describe different visits. In The Times of India, Shrinate tells the government "You invited Pakistan, and its minister, Musadik Malik, has arrived here," and attacks the "red carpet" laid out for him. Al Jazeera, relaying Indian media reports sourced to diplomats, says Delhi invited Khichi and Islamabad substituted Malik; The Tribune’s government sources describe a guest whose shrine request was refused. Shrinate’s version rests on a partisan argument; Al Jazeera’s on a single relayed report Islamabad has neither confirmed nor denied. Notably, no Indian official is on record in this coverage about Malik himself: Delhi speaks only through Jaiswal’s October briefing and unnamed security sources.

Room for disagreement

The case that this is more than ritual comes from people close to both governments. Dastgir told Al Jazeera that SCO meetings "can provide the pretext for bilateral communication, however rudimentary. Sidelines encounters need no announcement and no concession." Pakistan’s Foreign Office said Malik would meet SCO member states on the sidelines, and India is one. Rezaul Hasan Laskar of the Hindustan Times pointed to Track 1.5 and Track 2 contacts since months after the war and said such a visit "could be the pathway to opening all sorts of possibilities." Clearing four of five site requests, including the Taj Mahal, is itself more hospitality than a narrowly multilateral visit required.

Our assessment

It is very unlikely that Malik’s visit yields an announced India-Pakistan bilateral meeting before the forum closes on November 22. The warrant is on record and from both sides: Jaiswal’s statement that policy has not changed, Laskar’s account of the government’s no-bilateral line, former Indian envoy Sharat Sabharwal’s view that there is "no reason to look for any deeper meaning," and former Pakistani envoy Salman Bashir’s warning that the SCO offers "a semblance of civility" and not "a pathway to normalcy." Each party has a reason to keep it small: Delhi to deny Congress its red carpet, Islamabad to look like a constructive 2027 host without endorsing India’s showcase. The visit’s significance lies in that shared restraint, a rehearsal for Islamabad rather than a thaw.

What would change this: an Indian readout of a meeting between Malik and an Indian minister, or a Saturday speech that reopens the Goa-style exchange over terrorism.

Sources and evidence

Press quoted

🇮🇳
India
The Tribune
Original reporting
Pakistan minister gets nod to visit Taj Mahal, 3 Delhi sites; Nizamuddin shrine trip denied
Read →
🇮🇳
India
The Times of India
Original reporting
‘Rubbing salt into Pahalgam victims’ wounds’: Row over Pakistan minister at SCO meet in Delhi
Read →
🇵🇰
Pakistan
tribune.com.pk
Original reporting
Musadik Malik arrives in New Delhi to lead Pakistan delegation at SCO forum
Read →
🇹🇷
Turkey
Yeni Akit
TURKISH
Carries Indian Prime Minister’s Office reporting
A striking move from Modi at the Shanghai Cooperation Organisation summit! A critical visit from Pakistan to New Delhi after years!
“Modi’den Şanghay İşbirliği Örgütü zirvesinde dikkat çeken çıkış! Pakistan’dan yıllar sonra Yeni Delhi’ye kritik ziyaret!”
Read →
🇶🇦
Qatar
Al Jazeera
Original reporting
Pakistan minister visits India for first time since 2025 war
Read →
5 sources · each independently reported
Open questions
  • Will Malik’s address on November 21, where he said he would answer India’s terrorism concerns, bring an Indian rebuttal like Jaishankar’s attack on Bilawal Bhutto Zardari in Goa in 2023?
  • Why did Islamabad send its climate minister instead of the heritage minister India reportedly invited, and did New Delhi object to the substitution?
  • Will Malik have any sideline encounter with Indian ministers, and will the visit affect India’s still-undecided level of representation at the August 2027 SCO summit in Islamabad?

Share this story

That’s how the world told the story.

Get our daily open-source intelligence on world events in your inbox — one email a day, up to six stories.

Subscribe free

No spam. One-click unsubscribe. See the latest email →