AI-generated analysis published under the editorial responsibility of Rohit Sinnas. How it works →

See the 54 countries
Afghanistan, Argentina, Armenia, Australia, Austria, Azerbaijan, Belarus, Belgium, Brazil, Canada, Chile, China, Colombia, Croatia, Cyprus, Czech Republic, Dominican Republic, Egypt, France, Germany, Greece, Haiti, Hungary, India, Israel, Italy, Japan, Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Luxembourg, Mauritius, Mexico, Moldova, Morocco, New Zealand, Norway, Peru, Philippines, Poland, Portugal, Romania, Russia, Saudi Arabia, Serbia, Slovakia, Slovenia, Spain, Switzerland, Turkey, Tuvalu, Ukraine, United Kingdom, United States, Venezuela
COP31 in Antalya ran past its Friday close into Saturday. Agency reports say drafts dropped the COP28 fossil-fuel transition pledge and a $120 billion adaptation figure; Panama threatens to object; El Tiempo’s unnamed sources blame Arab states and Russia.
Across the press: Mersin Haber’s full account of Antalya’s closing plenary never mentions fossil fuels, the issue EFE and AFP copy in El Tiempo leads with.
Source base: 5 outlets quoted (Turkey, India, Japan, Colombia, Poland), selected from 60 analyzed. 3 read in full, 2 by their headlines only.
- 1 of 5 · El Tiempo onlyArab countries and Russia opposed the fossil-fuel transition language, and Gulf monarchies resisted overshoot wording in exchange for strong carbon-capture text.El Tiempo, citing ‘numerous sources’ and a Latin American source speaking to AFP. No named Arab or Russian official is quoted on the record.
- 3 of 5 · reported separatelyCOP31 in Antalya ran past its scheduled close on the evening of Friday, November 20, with delegations continuing on Saturday, November 21.Mersin Haber’s plenary account (Kurum announcing a third presidency draft for Saturday); El Tiempo citing EFE and AFP; The Daily Pioneer citing unnamed agencies.
- 2 of 5 · reported separatelyThe latest draft removed language on transitioning away from fossil fuels, the COP28 commitment, which had appeared in the first draft.El Tiempo citing EFE and AFP; The Daily Pioneer citing unnamed agencies, so overlap with AFP copy cannot be ruled out. Not mentioned in Mersin Haber’s plenary account.
- 2 of 5 · reported separatelyA figure of $120 billion a year in adaptation finance by 2035 was dropped from the revised draft.El Tiempo citing EFE and AFP, adding that an EU source ruled out more money over public debt; The Daily Pioneer citing unnamed agencies.
- 2 of 5 · reported separatelyPanama threatened to veto or formally object to any deal that does not address oil production and finance.El Tiempo quoting Panamanian environment minister Juan Carlos Navarro via EFE and AFP; The Daily Pioneer citing unnamed agencies.
- Saturday, November 21The Turkish presidency publishes its third draft decision, showing whether fossil-fuel transition language or an adaptation figure returns.
- Final plenary, November 21 or afterPanama and the 12-country group led by France and Panama decide whether to formally object to a text without fossil-fuel language.
- COP32, Addis AbabaEthiopia hosts the next summit, where the unresolved rules of procedure, including rule 42 on voting, return.
Full analysis
What happened Why it matters How each country tells it Room for disagreement Our assessment Sources and evidence
What happened
The United Nations climate summit in Antalya, Turkey, did not finish on time. COP31 was due to close at 6 p.m. on Friday, November 20, according to EFE and AFP reporting carried by Colombia’s El Tiempo, but with positions still apart its roughly 200 delegations were sent back to the table on Saturday. Chairing the closing plenary in the Anatolia Hall, Turkish environment minister Murat Kurum told delegates, in the account published by the Turkish regional site Mersin Haber: "We are close to the finish line. But we are not there yet." He said teams would compile results from midnight and that a third draft of the presidency’s decision would be published on Saturday, November 21.
The fight was over the text. According to El Tiempo’s agency account, language on transitioning away from fossil fuels, the commitment governments made at COP28 in Dubai in 2023, appeared in the first draft and was gone from the second, published Thursday. India’s Daily Pioneer, writing with agency inputs, reports the same of the latest draft. El Tiempo, citing "numerous sources," says Arab countries and Russia opposed the mention; no Arab or Russian official is quoted on the record. On the other side, a group of 12 countries led by France and Panama, including Spain, Guatemala, Côte d’Ivoire and Vanuatu, tabled a document calling for a "clear transition" out of oil, gas and coal. Panama’s environment minister, Juan Carlos Navarro, said: "We will veto or object to any proposal that does not address these issues." He called the consensus process "designed to fail," likening it to asking serial killers to guarantee everyone’s safety. Brazil, host of the 2025 summit, proposed a global roadmap for each country to chart its own exit from fossil fuels.
Turkey and Australia share the presidency, an arrangement El Tiempo calls unprecedented, and they argue the route out of fossil fuels runs through electrification. "Electrification is the key," said Chris Bowen, Australia’s climate minister. The draft would raise electricity’s share of global final energy use to 35 percent by 2035, from 23 percent today by El Tiempo’s figure; The Daily Pioneer notes the text does not clearly require the added power to be renewable, and El Tiempo reports some countries want it labeled "clean."
The draft reaffirms the 1.5-degree Celsius goal and asks for cuts that limit "both the magnitude and the duration" of an expected overshoot. El Tiempo reports, from an unnamed Latin American source speaking to AFP and its own sourcing, that Gulf monarchies resisted that wording and were compensated with strong text backing carbon capture; Spain’s climate office director, Elena Pita, called it "not acceptable" as drafted. On adaptation, the first draft put a number on the tripling promised at the Brazilian summit, $120 billion a year from 2035; the revision dropped it, and an EU source told the agencies the bloc could not add money given its public debt. "We have not come here to beg," said Ghana’s environment minister, Zanetor Agyeman-Rawlings.
Mersin Haber’s account records what the plenary did settle: decisions under Article 6 on carbon markets, support for developing countries under Article 13, least-developed-country items and an annual Global Stocktake dialogue. Rules of procedure stayed unresolved, with the draft rules applied except rule 42 on voting, which returns at COP32. Work on national adaptation plans and the Climate Technology Centre moves to the 66th session of the Subsidiary Body for Implementation. On the review of the long-term goal, China criticized developed countries for delaying it, and Saudi Arabia for the Arab Group, India for the Like-Minded Developing Countries, Chile and Palau for the small island states all backed keeping it. Panama, for the AILAC bloc, said some parties refused previously agreed language on 1.5 degrees and overshoot. Ethiopia’s foreign minister, Gedion Timotheos, confirmed COP32 for Addis Ababa. Kurum named the open issues as just transition, finance, emissions reduction and adaptation. The account never mentions fossil fuels.
Why it matters
If the transition language stays out, a COP decision three years after Dubai would no longer repeat what Dubai agreed, and the presidency’s electrification goal would stand in its place. Without a renewables qualifier, that goal can be met with gas-fired or coal-fired power, which is why it can be signed by producers who reportedly would not sign the words "fossil fuels."
The dropped adaptation figure was already small against the need. El Tiempo cites a UN Environment Programme estimate that developing countries will need about $305 billion a year for adaptation by 2035, against international public flows of $28.2 billion to $31.7 billion in 2024; tripling those flows would cover 20 to 29 percent. The Loss and Damage Fund received $2.8 billion in requests against $342 million available. Losing the one number in the text removes the yardstick vulnerable countries could hold donors to.
The deadlock also feeds a challenge to the format itself. Mexican legislator Laura Ballesteros said the COP format "is reaching its end," pointing to the absence of the United States; Guatemala’s environment minister, Edwin Castellanos, said his country gains more from bilateral deals. That the voting rule remains unadopted is the procedural root of Navarro’s complaint.
How each country tells it
- Mersin Haber · Turkey · wire copyAn item-by-item account of the closing plenary chaired by Turkish minister Murat Kurum: Article 6 carbon-market decisions adopted, rules of procedure, adaptation plans and technology work pushed to COP32, Ethiopia confirmed as COP32 host, and Kurum saying ‘we are close to the finish line, but not there yet’ with a third presidency draft due Saturday, November 21.
- The Daily Pioneer · IndiaA short, plain account leading on the overtime: the latest draft drops the COP28 transition-away-from-fossil-fuels language and the $120 billion annual adaptation target by 2035, keeps a 35 percent electricity-share goal without requiring renewables, and Panama threatens to object.
- Mainichi Shimbun · Japan · original reportingOnly the headline was available. It says talks were continuing with an extension ‘in view’ and that gaps remained over the draft outcome document.
- El Tiempo · Colombia · carries EFE and AFPThe fullest account. It covers the extension to Saturday, the first draft’s fossil-fuel transition language vanishing from the second draft published Thursday, the $120 billion adaptation figure disappearing, a Turkey-Australia co-presidency pushing electrification, and Panama’s environment minister Juan Carlos Navarro calling the consensus process ‘designed to fail.’ The piece builds toward whether the COP model itself still works.
- Rzeczpospolita (Klimat) · Poland · original reportingOnly the headline was available. It promises an explainer of what the countries at COP31 are clashing over, and its URL slug reads ‘fossil fuels are holding on tight.’
Room for disagreement
The presidency’s case is that the drafts are converging. Kurum said significant progress had been made, and a third draft was still to come; deleted language has returned in late drafts before, and a credible veto threat from a dozen countries including France is exactly the pressure that could bring it back. The blame is also less settled than it looks. The only named record of the Arab Group in plenary, in Mersin Haber, shows Saudi Arabia supporting continued review of the 1.5-degree goal, not obstructing it, and the charge against Arab states and Russia rests on unnamed sources in one agency account. Civil society voices such as Karla Maass of the Sacred Amazon Headwaters Alliance argue the consensus forum, flawed as it is, remains indispensable, which cuts against reading the overtime as the system’s collapse.
Our assessment
It is likely that whatever Antalya adopts will not restore the COP28 transition-away language in the form the first draft carried it. The removal is reported by two outlets, though The Daily Pioneer’s agency copy may overlap with AFP’s; Kurum’s own on-record list of open issues leaves fossil fuels off; and the co-presidency has publicly staked its outcome on electrification, with carbon-capture text reportedly traded for producer acquiescence. A consensus rule gives any objector leverage, but the objectors on this point are the producers, and the presidency’s framing already accommodates them. The host has an interest in describing the plenary as near agreement; Panama and its allies have an interest in describing it as sabotage. Readers should know the vantage is narrow: this set contains no Gulf, Russian or Australian outlet, the Indian piece says nothing of India’s position, and the Japanese and Polish reports could not be read, so who blocked what rests on one agency account.
What would change this: a third presidency draft that reinstates explicit transition-away-from-fossil-fuels wording, or Panama and the 12-country group formally blocking adoption in plenary.
Sources and evidence
Press quoted
- Will the presidency’s third draft, due Saturday, November 21, restore any fossil-fuel transition language or a dollar figure for adaptation finance?
- Will Panama carry out its threat to object, and could a single party’s objection stop adoption under COP consensus rules?
- Will Saudi Arabia, the Arab Group or Russia say on the record what they rejected, given that the only reports of their opposition come from unnamed sources?
That’s how the world told the story.
Get our daily open-source intelligence on world events in your inbox — one email a day, up to six stories.
Subscribe freeNo spam. One-click unsubscribe. See the latest email →